Should Transgender Rights Be Allowed Compete Sports

Bernadette Hollcraft Kline English March 12, 2016 Transsexuals and Athletics In the world today there is much controversy as to whether transgender people should be allowed to compete in sports because of fairness. Now that people are coming out more often, and as the subject of transsexuals is becoming more common, society is beginning to change ways to go about things daily. But what needs to be taken into account is when there should be a limit to change. In higher level sports, after puberty has been undergone, the realization that a man physically has an advantage over a woman is obvious. Yet all of the sudden, because of the fact that a man becomes a woman, or a woman becomes a man, people are challenging the rules of sports, and argue that transsexuals should still be allowed to compete with the new gender they identify with. However, there are fairness issues with this, and most importantly safety issues with this. In athletics, trans gender women have an advantage over women, and trans gender men have a disad vantage against men; Thus trans gender people should not be permitted to compete in athletics of the same gender they identify with. First, it is clear that the physiologies of a man versus a woman are very different in an abundant amount of ways. There is a reason in junior high the requirement mile times for guys are faster than requirement times for girls, and the requirements for the presidential fitness test that junior high students must undergo inShow MoreRelatedThe World Of Athletics Has Been Built Around A Binary View1634 Words   |  7 Pagesgender. The distinction between genders is obvious: there is women’s sport and there is men’s sport. However, in reality, gender biology is not black and white – there is a multitude of ways to be human. The separation of men’s and women’s sport leads to a large population of athletes getting stuck in the middle. There is a growing social acceptance of transgender and intersex individuals in society, however, when it comes to sport these individuals are often left isolated on an island of controversyRead MoreComparing Intersex And Transgender Females Deserve A Place Of Belonging1398 Words   |  6 PagesIntersex and transgender females deserve a place of belonging in the world of sport. Society’s need to categorize humans makes it difficult for minorities to find a sense of belonging. Humans are easily given labels by society - as gay, straight, black, asian, female, male etc. This system works for the majority of people, and those who fit in do not see a necessity to change these constructs. As Judith Butler argues in her essay Undoing Gender we must remake the definition of human by deconstructingRead MorePersuasive Essay On Transgenders1524 Words   |  7 PagesFemale sports are being ruined, because males are identifying themselves as females and competing with an unfair advantage. The biological men are causing a big problem around the world. They are breaking rec ords and winning competitions in wrestling, weightlifting, track, softball, volleyball, basketball, mixed martial arts, and more. Transgenders competing in women’s sports ask for equality, but it is proven that men are bigger and stronger than women, so they are making the sports unfair for theRead MoreThe Destruction Of Women s Sports1518 Words   |  7 PagesThe destruction of women’s sports is on the rise, because males are identifying themselves as females and competing with an unfair advantage. The biological men are causing a controversal problem around the world. These men are breaking records and winning competitions in wrestling, weightlifting, track, softball, volleyball, basketball, mixed martial arts, and more. Equality, is asked from the Transgenders who are competing in women’s sports, but it is proven that men are bigger and stronger thanRead MoreSports, Equality, And Act On The Locker Room Essay1632 Words   |  7 Pagesthe feeling that transge nders have from a young age. The feeling of not belonging in their own body and wanting to be someone else. To make things even harder, what if they were also an athlete? Not only would they feel like they don t belong in their own body, but the sports they want to play or already play would be affected. With that, this paper will look at and discuss eligibility in sports, equality in the locker room, and self worth both on and off the field for transgender athletes. SocietyRead MoreThe Destruction Of Women s Sports1465 Words   |  6 PagesThe destruction of women’s sports is on an upsurge, because males are identifying themselves as females and competing with an unfair advantage. The biological men are causing a controversial complication around the world. These men are breaking records and winning competitions in wrestling, weightlifting, track, softball, volleyball, basketball, mixed martial arts, and more. Requesting equality, the Transgenders are outraged about the regulations, but men are bigger and stronger than women, so theyRead MoreThe Thirty Nine Year Old New Zealand Weight Lifter1510 Words   |  7 Pagesisssue of the thirty-nine year old New Zealand weight lifter, Laurel Hubbard, a transgender woman who won the Australian International weightlifting competition. The following theories, Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics will be discussed to identify the ethical issues to justify whether this issue is fair for the other woma n competitiors. Before Hubbard arose as an international caliber lifter last year, she would compete nationally as ‘Gavin Hubbard’, which is her birth name. She started transitioningRead MoreThe Inclusion of Transgender Women in the Miss Universe1276 Words   |  6 Pagesin favor of a transgender woman from Canada by allowing her to compete among biologically-born female contestants in the said pageant. Subsequently, sentiments from different sectors go abuzz. Some give their nods of approval. Others though sneered. The Miss Universe beauty pageant continues to stew in controversy over the appeals of disqualified Canadian candidate Jenna Talackova, a transgender woman, with a former Miss Universe finalist rejecting the notion of contestants who sport male genitalsRead Moreessay about women studies1140 Words   |  5 Pagesï » ¿The first Olympic games where women were allowed to play were in 1900 summer Olympics, 4 years after the first formal Olympic games took place. Even though women were allowed to play at that time many countries just had only male delegations. This discrepancy, comes from a long time ago. Traditionally men have always been able to play sports, they were encouraged to be athletes because that made them fit and healthy. On the other hand, women has always been seen as inferior to man. As long as women’sRead MoreThe Rights Of American Citizens1217 Words   |  5 Pages Intersex Rights American citizens could be being treated unfairly when it comes to their sexual identity. An intersex human is one possessing any of several variations in sex characteristics including chromosomes, gonads, sex hormones, or genitals that, according to the U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights â€Å"do not fit the typical definition for male or female bodies†. Some people would argue that transgender individuals and intersex individuals are